We believe our denim and Stan Rays are meant to last a lifetime! However, things happen. Our sizes change, our taste evolves and you may change your mind somewhere down the line! Based on customer feedback we decided to create a Buy-Back Program for our Vintage Levi’s Denim and Stan Rays.

If you’re interested in trading in a pair of denim or Stan Rays and picking up a different color or style, this program is for you.

How Will It Work?

We will assess your Denim and Stan Ran’s on a case-by-case basis using an internal grading system. Based on the quality/condition of the item, we will offer you a credit that you may use to redeem your new pair of Stan Rays/Denim.

When bringing in your Stan Rays and/or denim to be assessed, we recommend:

1. Freshly washing your pants!
2. Spot treating any stains/marks.
3. Check for noticeable areas of wear and tear.


$35 credit (cream/white)

$40 credit (dyed)
$25 credit (all)
$15 credit (all)


$50 credit
$35 credit
$20 credit

Your FAQs, Answered


How is shipping calculated?

Shipping is based on weight for your entire order to give you the most accurate pricing.

Are your shipping materials recyclable?

Yes! We only source recyclable materials to pack and ship your order. From secondhand boxes to kraft mailers to USPS boxes, we use them all. We also try to avoid any plastics even if they may be recyclable.

Please make sure to recycle your shipping materials after your order. :)

How long does it take to ship my order?

Please allow 3 - 4 business days to process, pack and ship your order. We typically ship out orders on Tuesdays and Fridays depending on when the order was placed. If you've selected expedited shipping, allow 1 -2 business days to process, pack and ship. If you need same day delivery, contact us and we'll see if we can make it happen.

I live in the area, can I order an item online and pick it up in person?

Absolutely! Just enter the code INSTOREPICKUP at check out and your delivery fee will be waived. We will hold the item in the shop until you are ready to swing by and pick it up in person. Please provide provide first and last name along with proof of purchase when you make your way to the shop!


What is your return policy?

We know a pain point to vintage or secondhand shopping are returns so we will gladly accept returns under the conditions below:
    • We are contacted within 5 days of receiving your purchase.
    • Item(s) is returned in the condition it was purchased.
    • Buyer is responsible for return shipping.
    • Item(s) is shipped back within 3 days of contacting us.

Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, we cannot accept returns for:
    • Custom or personalized orders (ie. cropped denim or cropped Stan Rays)
    • Items on sale

To start the process for your return or answer any other questions about your order, please contact us at


I'm trying to buy vintage denim. Is a waist measurement the same thing as my "size"?

Particularly with vintage denim, sizing can be tricky. Because vintage denim does not have any stretch, you normally need to account for several inches of 'breathing' room to accommodate any movement in the denim. Nowadays a size 28 may actually measure out to a 30" waist especially if there is stretch.  Therefore you may fit a size 28 in a modern pair of denim, but you may actually have a 30" waist which the stretch accommodates for.

There are different ways of wearing vintage denim. You can go for a more loose fitting look or a more fitted look. This will also help you determine which "waist" size you should get.

Main thing to remember is that you normally need to size up as vintage denim does NOT have ANY stretch. So in case you want to breath or move around, you'll need an inch or two of room.

Do you list unisex sizing or women's sizing?

If you're shopping under the menswear filter, assume all sizing is unisex. For any clothing under the femme filter, assume the sizing is women's. The best way to get a sense of the correct size is to look at all measurements. This is going to be your best indicator. When shopping vintage, understanding your measurements is the key to successful shopping. :)


Do you ever offer any promos or discounts?

Yes! To be the first know, follow us on our instagram.

I have a question about my order. How do I contact you?

You can reach us at Please make sure to provide your name and order number so we can expedite a resolution or answer.

Copyright 2020 The Consistency Project
Copyright 2020 The Consistency Project